Video killed the Radio Star, part 2.
I think public Wi-Fi as a business model is pretty much dead in its current form. OK. So I'm not the first person to say this but having been one of the pioneers of the industry I had a lot of emotional baggage tied up in public Wi-Fi. It took me longer to see the light than most observers.
I'm not saying public Wi-Fi is dead. I think it has a fantastic future. But please! Just unlock every network and offer free access. Provide maintenance services to the location owners.
I think the business model has died because:
a). Complacency, hubris and inflexibility from the myriad group of pubic Wi-Fi operators around the world. Why didn't (wouldn't) you get together and offer access to anyone with a GSM-type roaming agreement? The fact that people have to fill out numerous online forms and get different user credentials is reason enough not to use this service.
b). The price. An average of $10 per day and as high as $40 a day in some places. Give me a break.
c). The Blackberry. What an absolutely superb device. I remember when the impact of the Blackberry over public Wi-Fi first struck me. I was in the waiting lounge at London City airport in late 2004. This is the perfect environment for public Wi-Fi. European business people in transit to and from London to the other financial centres around Europe. However, Swisscom were charging 15 *POUNDS* to get access. On top of that it was an absolute pain in the arse to sign up. I remember the day I noticed. 27 people in the lounge were on their Blackberries and two were connected to Wi-Fi. If you go back to the lounge today you will see 70% of people on their Blackberries and still, two people connected over Wi-Fi.
d). 3G. This is the final nail in the coffin. Most of the carriers are offering broadband wireless -- synchronous 256k service in reality. But that's usually enough for e-mail. For example 3 in the UK offers a fantastic deal: 10 Pounds a month (12 month contract) gets you a USB 3G dongle and about 3GB traffic a month throughout their worldwide network. Why the hell would you bother signing up to a Wi-Fi service if this is available.

